view your shopping cart Shopping Cart Help Contact Us Members of the Group
 
Log Off Guest 
Resources
Home + Quick Search
Alphabetical Listing
Journals by Subject
For Authors
For Librarians
FAQs
My Account
My Files
SARA (Contents Alerting)
Support Information
Library Recommendation Form
Article Back To:  Main    Publication    Issue 

    

Information, Communication & Society
  Publisher:  Routledge, part of the Taylor & Francis Group
  Issue:  Volume 6, Number 3 / September 2003
  Pages:  380 - 403
  URL:  Linking Options

The Shifting "Balance' Between Criminal Investigation and Privacy
A case study of communications interception law in the Netherlands


Bert-Jaap Koops A1

A1 Tilburg University

Abstract:

In the past decade, numerous ICT-related investigation powers have been introduced or extended. Have these shifted the balance between criminal investigation and privacy? Do governments allow more privacy infringements for the sake of law enforcement than they used to do? As a first step towards answering these questions, this paper presents the results of a case study of communications interception law in the Netherlands. The study offers a historical analysis of the introduction and changes in Dutch law regarding powers to investigate post, telegraphy, telephony, telecommunications, oral communications and traffic data in the period 1838- 2002. The case study shows that the balance between criminal investigation and privacy in Dutch law has shifted somewhat towards law enforcement, particularly in 2000, but privacy is not altogether discarded. Still, privacy does not appear to operate on a par with law enforcement: it seems a secondary rather than a primary factor in legislative practice. Governments and parliaments should pay more attention to substantiating the need for extending investigation powers, if they want to retain a semblance of truth when they speak of the "balance' between criminal investigation and privacy.

Keywords:

criminal investigation, privacy, communications, interception, Netherlands

The references of this article are secured to subscribers.

  
 Full Text Access
Full Text Secured

The full text of this article is secured to subscribers. To gain access, you may:

   Subscribe to this publication.

   Add this item to your shopping cart for purchase later.


   Purchase this item now.


    

 
Please Note: By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions of Access


Taylor & Francis Group

London • New York • Oslo • Philadelphia • Singapore • Stockholm
UK Head Office: 11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE
Email: Webmaster


Remote Address: 62.103.73.21 • Server: MPWEB09
HTTP User Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.6a) Gecko/20031030